Skip to main content
Clean Hydrogen Partnership

Hydrogen release when refuelling a train

Event

Event ID
1102
Quality
Description
The release occurred during refuelling of the mobile storage system. This operation was part of a series of tests aiming at verifying the tightness of the system.
When opening a valve to connect the dispenser to the high-pressure mobile storage system, a ferrule fitting failed, a tube was bended, and 450 bar hydrogen was released to the atmosphere.
The operator closed the valve as soon as possible. The release lasts a few seconds.
The loud noise of the high-pressure release caused hearing loss of different severity to the people that were in the area.
One person had a dislocation when running to escape from the incident.


The incident took place when preparing the dispenser for the tightness tests of the hydrogen powered train. Tightness tests up to a maximum of 450 bars had to be done as part of the factory tests of the train. A HRS developed for the project was expected to be used for those tests. Nevertheless, the development of that HRS has been delayed, and it was not available for the test. A dispenser and a 450 bar storage system from different manufacturer was rented instead.
The dispenser had been used with no incident at pressures up to 200 bar to fuel the train during previous tests. Some days before the incident, the 450 bar storage system was connected to the dispenser for a short period of time to the check the equipment, with no incident.
On the day of the incident, as soon as a valve in the storage system was opened to connect the dispenser to the storage system, the ferrule fitting of a pipe failed, and high-pressure hydrogen was released.
Event Initiating system
Classification of the physical effects
Unignited Hydrogen Release
Nature of the consequences
Leak No Ignition (No additional details provided)
Macro-region
Europe
Country
Spain
Date
Main component involved?
Joint/Connection (Threaded)
How was it involved?
Rupture
Initiating cause
Wrong Component
Root causes
Root CAUSE analysis
THe INTIATING CAUSE was a leack caused by the failing of the joint when testing a dispenser.

Two causes have been deemed most likely:
(1) An incorrect fixing of the ferrule fitting. The failed fitting was not originally part of the dispenser. It was added on site, and not tested.
or
(2) Vibrations during transportation. After being commissioned in manufacturer's facilities, the dispenser was moved to another two locations before going back to manufacturer location, traveling around 200 km. The dispenser was not checked after transportation.

The ROOT CAUSE could lie in (1) a deviation from the correct procedure during installation or (2) a missing step in the inspection of components (connections) when deviating from normal operations.

Facility

Application
Non-Road Vehicles
Sub-application
Fuel cells train
Hydrogen supply chain stage
Hydrogen Transfer (No additional details provided)
All components affected
pipe fitting, mobile connection
Location type
Open
Location description
Railway Or Train Station
Operational condition
Pre-event occurrences
The incident took place when preparing the dispenser for the tightness tests of the hydrogen powered train. Tightness tests up to a maximum of 450 bars had to be done as part of the factory tests of the train. A HRS developed for the project was expected to be used for those tests. Nevertheless, the development of that HRS has been delayed, and it was not available for the test. A dispenser and a 450 bar storage system from different manufacturer was rented instead.
The dispenser had been used with no incident at pressures up to 200 bar to fuel the train during previous tests. Some days before the incident, the 450 bar storage system was connected to the dispenser for a short period of time to the check the equipment, with no incident.
On the day of the incident, as soon as a valve in the storage system was opened to connect the dispenser to the storage system, the ferrule fitting of a pipe failed, and high-pressure hydrogen was released.

Emergency & Consequences

Number of injured persons
1
Number of fatalities
0
Environmental damage
0
Property loss (onsite)
0
Property loss (offsite)
0
Post-event summary
Release lasted a few seconds. No information on released quantity is available.
One person suffered a certain level of hearing loss. Some people suffered from temporary hearing problems, and evolved positively.
One person had a slight dislocation when running to escape from the incident.
No damage was caused to the equipment apart from the bended tube.

Lesson Learnt

Corrective Measures
The following actions were taken:
- To review ferrule fittings with measurement gauges.
- To perform tightness tests to the dispenser.
- To stablish procedures for checking the equipment after repair or transportation.
- To use of hearing protection.

Event Nature

Release type
gas
Involved substances (% vol)
H2 100%
Actual pressure (MPa)
20
Design pressure (MPa)
45
Presumed ignition source
No ignition

References

Reference & weblink

Own report available but confidential

JRC assessment