Skip to main content
Clean Hydrogen Partnership

Accidental formation and ignition of hydrogen due to corrosion

Event

Event ID
1012
Quality
Description
This event occurred at a theatre building. A contractor was conducting routine maintenance on a dry pipe sprinkler system in the basement of the theatre. By opening the pipe, an explosion occurred that caused burn injuries to the contractor.
The investigation concluded that the accident has been caused by hydrogen released into the sprinkler room from the sprinkler piping, when opening the sprinkler system. The released hydrogen formed a flammable mix with the air and ignited.
It is known that hydrogen forms in galvanised steel pipes, as a corrosion reaction product between zinc coating, oxygen from air and water.
The investigation could not identify the exact cause of the ignition.
Event Initiating system
Classification of the physical effects
Hydrogen Release and Ignition
Nature of the consequences
Macro-region
Europe
Country
Finland
Date
Main component involved?
Non-Hydrogen Component
How was it involved?
Accidental Release & Formation Of A Flammable H2-Air Mixture
Initiating cause
Accidental Hydrogen Formation
Root causes
Root CAUSE analysis
INITIATING CAUSE was the production of hydrogen from corrosion of zinc galvanic coating with oxygen and water.
The IGNITION CAUSE is unknown. But is plausible to assume that it came from a spark of the tools used by the maintenance contractor.
The ROOT CAUSE was the failing to foreseeing the possibility of hydrogen formation and to take the required preventing / mitigating measure

Facility

Application
Other
Sub-application
Water sprinklers
Hydrogen supply chain stage
All components affected
zinc-coated steel water pipe
Location type
Confined
Operational condition
Pre-event occurrences
Maintenance work was being carried out on the building facilities.

Emergency & Consequences

Number of injured persons
1
Number of fatalities
0
Environmental damage
0
Post-event summary
The maintenance contractor was injured

Lesson Learnt

Lesson Learnt
(see Tukes reference):
(1) Zinc-coated sprinkler pipes may form hydrogen gas, which can leak out during maintenance or other work on the sprinkler pipes, forming a flammable mix of hydrogen gas and air. This should be taken into account when assessing the danger of explosion and when required to draw up an explosion protection document.
(2) Sprinkler fitters must use a detector for hydrogen gas when emptying sprinkler pipes.
(3) A company that maintains sprinkler systems must device instructions for their employees that covers the ventilation of a facility, use of gas detectors, observation of pipe pressure, protective equipment and other equipment thought necessary.
(4) The sprinkler room’s ventilation should be ensured and boosted if needed when the sprinkler pipes are emptied or altered.
Corrective Measures

To avoid similar accidents, the national Safety and Chemical Agency recommended to avoid the use zinc-lined pipes in sprinkler systems.
Systems already under construction could be completed as planned, but the possible formation of hydrogen in the system piping had be taken into account to ensure safety.

Event Nature

Release type
gas
Involved substances (% vol)
H2 100%
Presumed ignition source
Mechanical sparks

References

Reference & weblink

tukes Finnish Safety and Chemicals Agency<br />
https://tukes.fi/en/-/hydrogen-explosion-caused-the-helsinki-city-theat… />
(accssed Dec 2022)

This incident is also analysed by R. Zalosh:<br />
Unusual hydrogen explosions due to unanticipated metal-water reactions <br />
Process Safety Process, 41 (2022) 120-127, DOI: 10.1002/prs.12288

Online news of The Nomad Today: <br />
https://www.thenomadtoday.com/articulo/finland/the-cause-of-the-acciden… <br />
(accessed Dec 2024)

JRC assessment